This isn't yet another thread about prop performance - it's about WEIGHT.
Yesterday I picked up my old Yamaha steel 3 blade OEM prop and another cheap aluminum 3 blade Solus prop that I bought a few years back, similar to the one I have currently mounted. The OEM was just plain more solid with thick internal gussets and weighed four times as much. That got me to wondering if I might be doing damage to the engine and drive train... There's a reason why Yamaha made the prop so heavy and solid - and I'm thinking it helps to dampen vibration and possibly gear backlash?
... and yes, I know that steel can survive a prop strike better than aluminum without fracturing, has less blade flex and is incrementally more efficient for high speed operation - so lets not "cavitate" into that discussion, thanks.
Any opinions?
There MUST be a reason my OEM prop weighs 4X aftermarket
Moderators: Redneck_Randy, badmoonrising, lakerunner
-
- Posts: 633
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2010 4:22 pm
Re: There MUST be a reason my OEM prop weighs 4X aftermarket
Nope. Stainless just weighs much more than aluminum. I have an OEM yamaha aluminum prop that came new on my yamaha 150 years ago. Very light compared to the stainless one that I replaced it with. Motor works fine with both.
Re: There MUST be a reason my OEM prop weighs 4X aftermarket
Really, your OEM steel prop weighs more then your aftermarket aluminum prop????
Weird.
Weird.
2012 SouthBay 722CRO 115hp Merc 4-stroke. Edit, make that a 150hp Merc 4-stroke now.
Re: There MUST be a reason my OEM prop weighs 4X aftermarket
"It's about weight"
Aluminum is about 1/3 the weight of steel. Everyone should weigh their prop and report back here when done.
Mine weighs 12# 7.75oz
It's an R3 14 1/4x17 SS prop
Aluminum is about 1/3 the weight of steel. Everyone should weigh their prop and report back here when done.
Mine weighs 12# 7.75oz
It's an R3 14 1/4x17 SS prop
Kenneth & Joy
Lake Conroe, Texas
2007 Bennington 2577RFSi
2006 Yamaha F225
Solas 14.25x17SS prop
Best ever top speed 69.2KPH
Lake Conroe, Texas
2007 Bennington 2577RFSi
2006 Yamaha F225
Solas 14.25x17SS prop
Best ever top speed 69.2KPH
Re: There MUST be a reason my OEM prop weighs 4X aftermarket
I lifted my old Yamaha 21 pitch stainless steel propeller yesterday to put it in a yard sale. I also picked up a Mercury 19 pitch aluminum prop at the same time. The stainless propeller was like picking up a chunk of lead.
Unfortunately, I had only one person out of 500+ bargain hunters even look at the props.
I used to tear up an aluminum propeller every year. I went 12 years on my first stainless propeller with hardly a scratch on it. Yes, they're worth the investment--especially on 150 hp or more.
Unfortunately, I had only one person out of 500+ bargain hunters even look at the props.
I used to tear up an aluminum propeller every year. I went 12 years on my first stainless propeller with hardly a scratch on it. Yes, they're worth the investment--especially on 150 hp or more.
'12 Bennington 24' SSLX Yamaha 150
-
- Posts: 633
- Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2010 4:22 pm
Re: There MUST be a reason my OEM prop weighs 4X aftermarket
[quote="Bamaman"]I lifted my old Yamaha 21 pitch stainless steel propeller yesterday to put it in a yard sale. I also picked up a Mercury 19 pitch aluminum prop at the same time. The stainless propeller was like picking up a chunk of lead.
Unfortunately, I had only one person out of 500+ bargain hunters even look at the props.
I used to tear up an aluminum propeller every year. I went 12 years on my first stainless propeller with hardly a scratch on it. Yes, they're worth the investment--especially on 150 hp or more.[/quote]
I think I'm going to file the leading edges of my old steel OEM prop, paint it and put it back on for comparison. I'm thinking the extra heft might help to reduce that gnarly long clunking I'm getting when shifting even if I do it rapidly. I couldn't help but notice what Yamaha has to say about their current SDS system - which wasn't available until 2010:
"The SDS system greatly reduces shifting noise and vibration. It’s what
we call “no-clunk” shifting. Ever since its fi rst day of availability, Yamaha’s
Shift Dampener System has been an instant hit. It’s so impressive, there is
a patent pending.
Using a specially-designed splined center hub and a uniquely shaped
aft spacer, the SDS system absorbs much of the force resulting from an
outboard shifting into forward or reverse gear. That means noticeably
quieter and smoother shifting."
Unfortunately, I had only one person out of 500+ bargain hunters even look at the props.
I used to tear up an aluminum propeller every year. I went 12 years on my first stainless propeller with hardly a scratch on it. Yes, they're worth the investment--especially on 150 hp or more.[/quote]
I think I'm going to file the leading edges of my old steel OEM prop, paint it and put it back on for comparison. I'm thinking the extra heft might help to reduce that gnarly long clunking I'm getting when shifting even if I do it rapidly. I couldn't help but notice what Yamaha has to say about their current SDS system - which wasn't available until 2010:
"The SDS system greatly reduces shifting noise and vibration. It’s what
we call “no-clunk” shifting. Ever since its fi rst day of availability, Yamaha’s
Shift Dampener System has been an instant hit. It’s so impressive, there is
a patent pending.
Using a specially-designed splined center hub and a uniquely shaped
aft spacer, the SDS system absorbs much of the force resulting from an
outboard shifting into forward or reverse gear. That means noticeably
quieter and smoother shifting."